Struggling to figure out if you want to buy a new or used car?

Here is a detailed description of the advantages and disadvantages of buying a new or used car for buyers who are interested in buying a car. 

When buying a car, there are a list of things that a buyer should be considering:

• Budget
• Make and Model
• Features
• Safety Ratings
• Fuel Efficiency
• Cost of Insurance
• Lifestyle   

The buyer must also keep in mind that the cost of the car is not the only payment involved, the buyer should be prepared for any maintenance and fuel costs.

As proper routine and unexpected maintenance is important for keeping a car in good condition over time. 

Needs Vs Wants: 

Buyers should keep in mind their “needs vs wants,” for a vehicle.

An example of a need is the safety sensors that are in the car, as it can keep the driver and any passengers safer than a car without those safety precautions.

Wants could involve a heated steering wheel, while it may be a nice feature that could seen as a need, a buyer should prioritize safety over practicality. 

Interviews From Current Car Owners: 

According to Brunswick High School Career Coach, Randy Kelly, he shares some of his insight on buying a car.

“Buying a new or used car depends on your circumstance around how you want to purchase the vehicle, if its something you’re wanting to hold onto as family or legacy purchase or wealth purchase,” Kelly said. “You definitely want to buy it, let’s say like a collectible. If it’s something you’re using just as a daily driver I think it’s best to purchase it because depreciation is a real thing when it comes to automotives. And you don’t want to be in a situation where you’re paying to impress the road. You want to have a vehicle that you can get a good amount of use out of, but still not be responsible for all the depreciation that comes from a new car.”

Kelly shares how important depreciation is for buying a vehicle new. It’s a valid point for consideration when deciding to buy a new vehicle. As of early 2026, the average new vehicle depreciates by approximately 41.8% over five years.

Mr. Robert Beavan, a Career and College Prep teacher at Brunswick High School suggests buying a used car for any younger drivers looking to make a car purchase.

“It really depends upon what you’re going to be using the car for…” Beavan said. “I often suggest to younger people that they buy a used car because they won’t be putting as many miles on it as someone who has a job where they will be depend upon their car for transportation, so typically I recommend a used car for cost to keep the cost down for the student.”

If you have any questions about any financial or college assistance, feel free to reach out to Randy Kelly or Robert Beavan within the school to help with big purchase decisions, like cars.